Supper Punch!!! (Week 6)

The Dawson/Carnam domination of Supper Punch!!! has come to close, thanks to Sarah Bonkosvky and her much-admired sweet potato and ginger soup last week. Way to go, Bonko! And now, on to week 6…

Voting for Supper Punch!!! week 6 is now closed. Congratulations to our winner, Ross Catrow! Thanks to everyone who voted — and be sure to tune in tomorrow for week 7.

The Dawson/Carnam domination of Supper Punch!!! has come to close, thanks to Sarah Bonkosvky and her much-admired sweet potato and ginger soup last week. Way to go, Bonko! And now, on to week 6…

For those of you new to Supper Punch, here’s how it works:

Each week, four local food enthusiasts submit two photos and a brief commentary (including helpful tips and prep time) on a recently-completed dish of their choosing. You, our readers, will then declare a winner for the week by voting in the comments. Your vote can be based on whatever you like: creativity, good use of local products, what you want to put in your belly at that exact moment, whatever.

Our competitors:
Sarah Bonkovsky, a gluten-free mother of three who loves to eat food from her own and nearby gardens. She also describes herself as “slightly lazy, distracted, and messy in the kitchen.” Don’t let her self-deprecating tone fool you — she can BRING IT.

Jennifer Carnam, Vice President of Marketing for the Richmond Metropolitan Convention & Visitors Bureau (RMCVB) with 30+ years of experience. She’s a California native, a Boston Red Sox fan (by marriage), wife to Allyn, mother to Lex, and step-mother to Lincoln and Todd. She is also the most fun.

Ross Catrow, co-founder of local web design firm PharrOut, lover of beer, butter, and his family. He’s perhaps best-known as the master and commander of the good ship RVANews. Occasionally he takes a picture or two (you can see documentation of his Supper Punch candidates here).

Nick Dawson who recalls early memories of watching PBS cooking shows while home sick from school. By day he works in hospital administration, focusing on improving on the patient experience; by night he is a fan of all things porcine, a curer of meats, a producer of pickles, and a lover of simple foods done very well. He describes himself as “passionate about local, sustainable foods and their producers.”

Our current standings are:
Bonkovsky: 1 (winning week 5)
Carnam: 2 (winning weeks 2 and 3)
Catrow: 0
Dawson: 2 (winning weeks 1 and 4)

Let’s get started…

Bonkovsky: Rock Cornish Game Hen

I’ve only recently started cooking whole poultry. I was a little intimidated at first, I’ll admit. And for a while I wanted nothing to do with raw meat (those combined 27 months of pregnancy). Lately, I’ve come back to the idea, partly due to the encouragement of a friend and my sister who both seem to cook these little guys with ease. A smaller bird cooks more quickly so that means less forethought from me. I rubbed them with olive oil, lemon juice, rosemary, garlic, salt, and pepper, stuffed some lemon and rosemary inside and cooked them for about an hour. My house smelled incredible. For one of the sides I cooked some green beans with almost exactly the same ingredients as I put on the chicken. I also made some red quinoa with onions, chives, craisins, red wine vinegar, and olive oil.

My son especially loved eating this chicken. He has asked every night since then if we were having the leftover “hen”. I think he liked seeing the whole bird and realizing a little bit more where his food comes from — heartless carnivore.

After dinner, I saved the leftover meat to be made into another meal and made a stock with the bones, some carrots and some celery. It’s the dinner that keeps on giving.

Time spent
Prepping the hens: 10 minutes
Cooking: 1 hour

Carnam:Lemon-Rosemary Roasted Free-Range Chicken with Purple Sweet Potatoes in Orange Cups

Slightly cooler temps and a little bit of rain signaled all systems go for firing up the double ovens this week. Taking my daughter Lex’s advice to task, I juxtaposed the sweet with the savory and indulged my fascination with fall colors. A 5 lb free-range chicken got stuffed with sweet onion, sliced lemon, and fresh rosemary from the deck herb garden. More rosemary and a little bit of butter went under the skin before I trussed the bird with kitchen twine to keep everything neat during the roasting and basting process. Always inspired by my muse, Julia Child, I made sure to baste the bird every 10-12 minutes throughout its 2 hour solitary confinement in the oven. (I basted with some melted butter and white wine until the juices started to flow, then used that.)

For the side dish, I hollowed out some navel oranges, reserving the juice. Meanwhile, I peeled and boiled purple sweet potatoes (because purple and orange look great together) which were then drained, mashed and beaten with egg whites, vanilla and orange juice. I filled the orange cups with the potato mixture, then topped with a combination of brown sugar, butter, a little flour and chopped pecans. After adding about 1/2 inch water to the dish, the stuffed oranges baked for about 30 minutes.

With a nice glass of Pouilly Fume, this dinner really hit the spot, and gave me just the fuel I needed for my Sunday night TV double date with Nucky Thompson and Don Draper.

Time spent
About 2 hours

Catrow: Tortellini and a Passable Tomato Sauce (with Arugula)

Guys. I was on vacation this whole week — it’s a miracle I made even a single dinner, let alone something picture worthy. But somehow, between all the quality time with my child and wife, I managed to throw this together.

Something everyone should know how to make is a passable tomato sauce. This one is particularly easy: sauté some onions and garlic, throw in a can of diced tomatoes & a can of crushed tomatoes, and a couple tablespoons of butter. Cook for awhile until it begins to thicken up. You can fancify things up by adding any of the following: wine, meat (cook it first and sauté the onions in the fat), brown sugar, jalapenos, curry — I mean almost anything.

You can freeze the crap out of this too, or just keep it in your fridge and eat off it for a couple days. I used the leftovers on a killer pizza the following night.

As for the tortellini, sure sure it is store bought. I’m not trying to spend the next six hundred hours folding, crimping, and cutting pasta. Not my idea of fun. These particular guys came from Costco and contained a minimal number of ingredients I couldn’t pronounce.

I tossed the pasta with some fresh Parmesan and a couple handfuls of chopped arugula. Bam, dinner.

PS: This week’s photos were taken with the amazing toy camera application Hipstamatic.

Time spent
40 minutes

Dawson: Beer Braised Knockwurst — Oktoberfest Style

Although Mother Nature does not seem to have read the post on her Facebook wall, it is indeed fall. Over the last few weeks, Germans have been celebrating the arrival of Autumn in style — Oktoberfest! Does it get any more quintessential than frothy beer and sausages? This week, I broke out the grinder — ok maybe I do that every week, everyone has to have a hobby, right? – and set about to make some fresh garlic and sage knockwurst.

Like so many of their porcine brethren before it, a shoulder of local natural pork when through the die of my grinder along with salt, sage, garlic, and chilies. Rather than use the traditional white wine, I opted for a generous dosage of Founders Breakfast Stout. The sausages were then packed into casings.

For dinner that night, two of the knocks were poached in the same Breakfast Stout until they reached about 130F inside. The sausages were transferred to a hot pan for a quick browning. Meanwhile, the remaining stout was left to reduce to a thick gooey glaze. The sausages went into some rolls lined with whole grain mustard, some home pickled onions that had been sweated down to a sticky mess and some Bubbies sauerkraut (if you don’t know Bubbies pickles and kraut, run don’t walk to the store and find them!).

Now, I’m a purest. From there I’d have called our German-inspired, artery clogging, heartburn-producing creation done. But, the gilded lilly called, as it is wont to do, so we topped these bad boys with some cloth-aged Grafton cheddar and stuck them under the broiler to get even more GBD (golden, brown and delicious). Just before serving, I drizzled them both with the Founders Breakfast Stout glaze — a newly invented, soon-to-be staple condiment in the Dawson house which seems to have more in common with Vegimite than anything else — pure umami!

Now, tell me you don’t hear the oomph band playing in your mind? Happy Oktoberfest!

Time spent
1 hour

Wow. Tough competition this week. Leave your votes in the comments.

  • error

    Report an error

Comments are closed.

  1. Knock, knock.

    Who’s there?


  2. Bonkovsky almost had me, but I’m such a sucker for sweet potatoes, Carnam gets my vote this week.

  3. Bonk! I’m proud of her for getting over her whole bird aversion. And anyone who has been pregnant for over two years of her life deserves a win.

  4. Lincoln Carnam on said:

    I’ve got to share this with everyone, those sweet potato filled orange shells were almost like desert they were so good. I had a second one yesterday and they were just as good two days later. This week I have to go with Carnam. WOW!!

  5. Brooke on said:

    My love of oranges pulled me to Carnam for the win. Who would of thought of oranges and potatoes? But they look so delicious and beautiful!

  6. Catrow. He cooked on staycation, people. At least two meals. And, his son is eating dinner without a shirt on.

  7. Catrow for the hipster style images. I expect to see him in black cut-off jorts on a scooter with a PBR in hand any day – Go Ross go!
    Oh, and the food looks amazing too! You are spot on, a good tomato sauce is such a staple.

  8. Catrow wins the cutest kid vote, for sure, but I have to vote Carnam this week. Although those purple sweet potatoes were absolutely divine, even though they looked like something Willy Wonka would eat.

  9. Michelle on said:

    Carnam gets my vote…. those sweet potatoes looked yummy!! A perfect meal for the kick off to Fall.

  10. Carrie on said:

    Dawson: who can pass up an Oktoberfest meal?!

  11. John B on said:

    I like the hens. I’ve been scared to try them, but Sarah made them look easy!

  12. I vote Carnam for the purple goo and the complement with the orange.

  13. Catrow. Quick and simple, ftw!

  14. Carnam for her creativity and her patience. I think Julia would be proud.

  15. Catrow gets my vote this week because I’ve been craving tortellini, and that looks delicious. I’m tempted to replicate it tonight for my dinner. And I’m IN LOVE with the hipster pics – that camera app thingy is neat.
    Dawson, however, gets a very honorable mention for beautiful photography and, per usual, the most complex entry in the running.

  16. Everything looked delicious and fairly easy to prepare – but – chicken, sweet potatoes and oranges started my mouth watering. It is a recipe I will definitely try.

    My vote is for Jennifer Carnam.

    Thank you, Jennifer for your Carnam:Lemon-Rosemary Roasted Free-Range Chicken with Purple Sweet Potatoes in Orange Cups

  17. While I’m bummed to see the end of summer, there’s not much better than knockwurst…and beer. Way to go Dawson. This vote’s for you.

  18. This is easy, Dawson.

    I am not a typical brat kinda gal but these were off the hook! the glaze was seriously amazing as was every part of every bite.

  19. Ryan Smartt on said:

    Catrow. Dude NEEDS to get on the scoreboard. And who can resist a picture of a shirtless JR eating? Nobody. That’s who.

  20. Chalk up another vote for Carnam! Anyone who’s not afraid to use real butter wins my affection!

  21. Jeannea Spence on said:

    Wow! Nuts, butter, and sweet potatoes…and purple ones at that! I’m showing up at Jennifer Carnam’s house and begging for this dish. I want to cast two votes — one for the dish and another for the leftovers. Well, now that I think about it there probably wouldn’t be any leftovers :-)

  22. Must… resist… power… of… cute baby.

    Dawson MADE his own sausage. That’s gross, and awesome. And win worthy.

  23. Purple sweet potatoes??!! I have to vote Carnam.

  24. Who said you have to wear a shirt when eating Tortellini’s. Nobody!!Catrow gets the vote!

  25. Wait, do you guys eat with shirts on normally?


  26. Man, another tough one.
    I’m going with Dawson because that’s what I most want to eat and drink at this very moment. But don’t sleep on Carnam, I’ll tell you that much.

  27. Catrow. nuff’ said.

  28. Crap. They all look delicious but I’m a guy. And I like beer. And I like sausage. DAWSON for the neanderthal vote.

  29. I don’t usually vote, because most weeks I simply cannot choose. But Ross’s begging is getting to me, and his is the meal this veggie mom would eat.

    (OK, that’s a lie: I want the purple taters and the sausage, because I bet Nick’s started with pork I could trust . . . )

  30. Okay, okay, son. Here is one pity vote.

  31. Ross. Best pity vote I ever voted.

  32. Nick gets the vote. That’s going to be one DGK (damn good knockwurst). Where are the beer pairing suggestions?

  33. Charlotte on said:


  34. Nancy on said:

    Carnam gets my vote for sure…that meal truly looks delish! You definitely did Julia proud.

  35. Jennifer’s obsession with antioxidant-rich meals is commendable.

  36. It IS Octoberfest, folks. Tomato sauce and Cornish game hens on a good day belong in another seasonal preparation of, say eating red crow? Dawson rocks. Rolls are next week.

  37. PS. Seven weeks is long enough for these competition things…unless you want to see @ketilave vs @kindnessgirl vs I don’t know… a pediatrician with bunch of kids, no camera and an aversion for brussel sprouts…

  38. Catherine on said:

    Grafton cheddar did it for me. Dawson.

  39. Catrow – for the pics, but also because I will probably retain that info and use it tomorrow or the next day.

  40. Bonko! Bonko! Bonko!

  41. Catrow for the use of color this week.

  42. Bonkovsky…it looks delish and I’d eat cornish game hen even if it were sauteed in kitty litter.

This article has been closed to further comments.