Total Recall: I recall the first one fondly!

You’d think moviegoers would get bored of watered down versions of movies they’ve already seen–but no! The onslaught of sequels and remakes continues with Total Recall.

Question: have we run out of ideas for new movies?

Preceding Total Recall, 100% of the previews were of either remakes/sequels or Quentin Tarantino1 movies. They’re remaking Red Dawn2 for Pete’s sake! Has it always been this way? I don’t remember seeing any sequels for Bringing Up Baby (Look Who’s Bringing Up Baby Now!), The Maltese Falcon (The Maltese Falcon Flies Again: A Fat Man’s Tail), or Citizen Kane (Citizen Kane 2: Rosebuddies). But here we are, neck deep in rehashes of movies that maybe weren’t all that great the first time around.

You’d think moviegoers would get bored of watered down versions of movies they’ve already seen–but no! The theatre was packed with either 1) people that were teenagers when the original Total Recall came out or 2) the offspring of people that were teenagers when the original Total Recall came out.

This particular Total Recall is a remake of the 1990 film starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and has enough plot tweaks to make it feel newish. Set in 2084 after a world-wide chemical war has left the majority of earth uninhabitable, the film follows Douglas Quaid (Colin Farrell) a humble yet handsomely ripped construction worker. Quaid lives in The Colony (present day Australia) and commutes each day to the United Federation of Britain (present day Britain) via an elevator through the center of the earth–which, honestly, talk about government spending! Dubbed The Fall, the elevator brings tens of thousands of blue collar workers through the center of the earth to work depressing factory jobs for the white-collar British aristocracy.3

Quaid lives a boringly normal construction worker’s life, married to a beautiful EMT named Lori (Kate Beckinsale, Those Underworld Movies). His nights are plagued by strange dreams of Schwarzenegger-like action sequences starring himself and a strange woman (Jessica Biel, 7th Heaven4). Because life in The Colony is pretty shitty and because Quaid thinks he might be going just a little bit crazy, he decides to visit Rekall, a company specializing in implanting memories. For a fee, Rekall will implant all the pleasant memories not afforded by your current life, letting you “remember” your time as a rockstar, orgymaster, or secret agent. However, if you already have any of these memories the procedure can go horribly wrong, causing your mind to irreparably conflate real and fake memories. Quaid chooses the secret agent package and…the procedure goes horribly wrong!

Philip K. Dick wrote the original story, We Can Remember It for You Wholesale, on which the Total Recall universe is based. This newest incarnation heavily borrows visuals from Blade Runner, another Philip K. Dick story; Minority Report5; and Star Wars. The Colony looks like it was lifted straight out of Blade Runner’s Los Angeles, and works as a great setting for Beckinsale to chase Farrell around. The United Federation of Britain is less detailed but sports a sweet hovercar highway (vehicles hover on and hang below the road) for all of your action-movie-car-chase needs. And The Fall is really the visual centerpiece–it’s even kind of based on quasi realish science!

The characters aren’t especially deep, which is OK I guess. Beckinsale’s character had potential but fell short, and Biel plays the typical helpless female in need of rescuing. At some point Beckinsale’s pursuit of Farrell, which starts out terrifyingly, becomes a snoozeville catfight between her and Biel. Farrell does a decent enough job playing an emotional, confused dude but can’t hold a candle to Schwarzenegger’s performance. That’s because Quaid is supposed to be a construction worker looking for a more interesting life that emerges from the Rekall procedure completely at a loss and out of his depth! It works better when he’s kind of dumb (no offense, former Governor!).

If you’ve seen the original Total Recall you’re probably going in looking for three things (warning, spoilers from 1990 ahead):

  • Triple boob (NSFW) — I’m pleased6 to say that the triple boob remains and will excite yet another generation of teenage boys.
  • The Nose Scene — Augh, I couldn’t even get through rewatching this scene on YouTube. While a similar scene exists in the new movie, it’s been disappointingly toned down.
  • Kuato — “QUAAAAID!” Sadly, Kuato’s been entirely cut from this remake.

So it’s a mixed bag for those who wish to relive old Total Recall memories. Honestly, I’d just Netflix the original or have the memories of Arnold pulling a golf ball out of his nose artificially implanted.

— ∮∮∮ —

Why you should see this movie

You were born sometime between 1970 and 1980, or you have a thing for three-boobed mutant women. Also, if you’re a sucker for good scenery.

Why you should stay home

Maybe after feeling deep emotions while watching Katniss in The Hunger Games, you’ll no longer put up with science fiction movies hastily throwing together two-dimensional female characters. Or maybe you’d just like to see an original storyline for once?

— ∮∮∮ —


  1. Which, to be fair, kind of all looked like remakes of other Quentin Tarantino movies. 
  3. Or something. Honestly, how great can life be, even for the aristocracy, if 90% of the world is a ruined, toxic mess? They do have hovercars so that’s something, I guess. 
  4. You just can’t trust Mary. 
  5. Minority Report really changed the world, didn’t it? Since its 2002 release, every single futurecomputer is a transparent, floating touch screen. People in the future must have incredibly toned upper bodies after spending the entire workday holding their arms straight out. 
  6. I guess I’m pleased? Teenaged Ross would be pleased, at least. 
  • error

    Report an error

Ross Catrow

Founder and publisher of RVANews.

Notice: Comments that are not conducive to an interesting and thoughtful conversation may be removed at the editor’s discretion.

  1. Bruce Wells on said:

    I saw it last night ($6 ticket night at the Bow Tie) and was not impressed. I would not recommend it nor would I see it again (even for free). It was not the worst movie I have ever sat through (that honor goes to the Seth Rogan stinker Green Hornet) but nonetheless save your money. Oh and btw, I had the same feeling watching the trailers (upcoming remakes) as you did. I kept thinking What the what?

  2. Tony on said:

    I read elsewhere that Minority Report (also a Dick story), which Farrell was in, was originally conceived as a sequel to Total Recall.

    When I saw that this movie was coming, I suspected it might be better-made (written, directed, acted, etc.) and still be a worse movie. The Robocop retread may suffer the same fate.

  3. Went and saw Total Recall today. Holy shit it was awesome!

  4. JoeyG on said:

    I don’t understand where these reviews come from really. Its a guys movie. Futuristic, hot chicks, hot chicks fighting each other, explosions, guns and chase scenes. What plot are you expecting when you go see a movie like this? I thought it was exactly what I wanted it to be, freakin awesome! Maybe you would like the new Tommy Lee Jones/ Streep movie better…

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with an asterisk (*).

Or report an error instead